Real news, fake news, or "up-to-you": Journalism & The Trump-Russia dossier leak

This “transparent” flow of unverified information could be both desirable and dangerous.

  /  01.12.2017

Wednesday morning (January 11), President-Elect DonaldTrump held his first press conference since summer 2016. That’s extraordinary timing in itself, but all the moreso given Tuesday’s explosive reports by CNN and BuzzFeed of a memo suggesting Russian president Vladimir Putin had been “cultivating” Trump as an unwitting asset, feeding him intelligence while simultaneously compiling compromising information against him in an effort to control him and disrupt the international alliance that Putin views as inconvenient to Russian interests. Sounding like a movie plot—almost is a movie plot—it certainly set the stage for a memorable press conference — and for a pivotal conversation in the ethics, and existence, of journalism.

Trump’s incoming Press Secretary Sean Spicer set the tone by dismissing the reports and their underlying intel out-of-hand, grouping the CNN and BuzzFeed reports as essentially one and the same. Except, they contain a crucial distinction: CNN reported, based on their direct sources, that this memo existed and had been presented both to Trump and President Obama, but stopped short of reporting on the memo’s allegations because they hadn’t yet been verified; BuzzFeed, on the other hand, published the entire memo, explicitly noting that it contained factual errors and leaving readers to “make up their own minds.”

This is a momentous and unprecedented editorial stance for a “reliable” news source to take with unsubstantiated information. In a memo to staff, BuzzFeed Editor-In-Chief Ben Smith said that it was not an easy decision, but that he chose to publish the memo in the interest of “transparency,” as this document had been circulating government and media hands for some time.

“Publishing the dossier is how we see the job of reporters in 2017,” Smith added.

With that, BuzzFeed has precipitated a new debate in journalistic ethics while CNN adhered to standards and conventions of publishing only verified material. In Trump’s eyes, however, they are one and the same: “fake news.” That’s the rationale he gave, explicitly, in ignoring CNN’s Jim Acosta at his press conference. And it’s the most recent example of the term “fake news” being removed from its root (news that is completely fabricated) and weaponized.

To reiterate: CNN didn’t publish the memo, only the fact that it existed and its underlying claims, which were credible enough that the intelligence community elected to present them to both the president and president-elect.

All of this sets off a series of questions:

First, what is “fake news”? And when is news “real news” to Donald Trump? (In this case, the CNN report is based on independent verification and limited to substantiated facts. The memo itself contained unverified allegations from anonymous sources, the hallmarks of the sort of “fake news” which diluted Facebook discourse this past year.) Whatever the case, today’s incident illustrates how “fake news” as a term has been weaponized, and may be invoked to delegitimize any report or information someone finds adversarial or inconvenient.

Second, what is the role of reporters in 2017? Is it simply to report the existence of content or to ensure that content’s veracity and truthfulness before sharing? If the former, what is the difference between a “reporter” and a “person with an internet platform/social media account”? If the latter, see the first question (i.e. What are the standards for “real” and “fake” anymore? As Kanye would say, “Do anybody make real sh-t anymore?” Fair question, ‘Ye. Fair enough.)

Third, what is more important in reportage: transparency or accuracy? Is it asking too much of readers to “make up their minds for themselves”? Is the general reader sophisticated enough (in background knowledge, in independent channels of information and verification) to really make up their minds in objective ways? Or does this just allow people to decide facts for themselves based on their prejudices, biases, and opinions?

Fourth, is the “transparent” flow of unverified information desirable or dangerous?

Let me know what you think on social media (@amritsingh). Let’s feed the conversation before the conversation feeds on us.



View More



View More


Walmart has the home essentials for everyone on your holiday shopping list

Below, our gift guide highlights some of our favorite Walmart finds for anyone in need of a home refresh.

  /  11.24.2023

Walmart's HBCU Black and Unlimited Tour kicks off at Central State University

On Oct. 10, Walmart unveiled a brand new, state of the art creative studio on the campus of Central State University.

  /  11.14.2023

The Walmart HBCU Black & Unlimited Tour visited Mississippi Valley State University

The Walmart HBCU Black & Unlimited Tour made its final stop at Mississippi Valley State University (MVSU) and left a lasting impact on students and alumni alike.

  /  11.22.2023

5 things you need to know about the 2023 Billboard Music Awards

“REVOLT Black News” correspondent Kennedy Rue counts down the top five moments from the 2023 Billboard Music Awards, including surprising wins, historic firsts, and dope performances. Sponsored by Amazon.

  /  11.20.2023

Walmart continues HBCU Black & Unlimited Tour during lively Virginia State University stop

After unveiling their state of the art creative studio on the campus of Central State University, Walmart brought the HBCU Black & Unlimited Tour to Virginia State University (VSU) on Oct. 13.

  /  11.14.2023

Walmart HBCU Black & Unlimited Tour brings attention and wisdom to North Carolina Central University

On Oct. 17, Walmart brought the third stop of the HBCU Black & Unlimited Tour to North Carolina Central University (NCCU).

  /  11.15.2023

Walmart's HBCU Black and Unlimited Tour kicked off at Central State University

In October, Walmart unveiled a brand new, state of the art creative studio on the campus of Central State University. The HBCU located in Wilberforce, OH was the first stop on Walmart’s Black and Unlimited HBCU Tour.

  /  11.28.2023

Groovey Lew on hip hop style, Johnell Young's industry secrets, BGS salon's wig mastery and more | 'Black Girl Stuff'

Fashion King Groovey Lew on masterminding hip-hop’s most iconic looks. Actor Johnell Young reveals the secret to breaking into the entertainment industry. Celebrity hairstylist Dontay Savoy and got2B ambassador Tokyo Stylez are in the BGS Salon with the perfect wig install. Plus, comedian Lauren Knight performs.

  /  11.15.2023

Pheelz talks expressing himself through music & his biggest inspirations | 'On In 5'

On this all-new episode of “On In 5,” multitalented Nigerian artist Pheelz opens up about waiting for his opportunity to fully express himself through music, his inspirations and emotions, and the musical icons he grew up admiring. Watch!

  /  07.11.2023

Kareem Cook talks growing up in The Bronx, studying at Duke & networking | 'The Blackprint with Detavio Samuels'

On this all-new episode of “The Blackprint with Detavio Samuels,” the host and REVOLT CEO sits down with Kareem Cook. Throughout the introspective episode, Cook talks growing up in The Bronx, studying at Duke and being nervous to be in the South at the time, network vs. education, taking advantage of your opportunities, and connecting with Debbie Allen. Watch!

  /  07.10.2023

Tiffany Haddish on therapy, wild fan interactions & the upcoming 'Haunted Mansion' movie | 'The Jason Lee Show'

On this all-new episode of “The Jason Lee Show,” the one and only Tiffany Haddish sits for a must-watch conversation about wild interactions with fans, her new movie ‘Haunted Mansion,’ bringing her therapist on dates, and being present. Watch the hilarious interview here.

  /  07.12.2023

Dig In & Drink Up | 'Bet on Black'

In this new episode of ‘Bet on Black,’ food and beverage take center stage as aspiring Black entrepreneurs from It’s Seasoned, Black Farmer Box, and Moors Brewing Co. present their business ideas to judges with mentorship from Melissa Butler. Watch here!

  /  11.15.2023

BNXN talks leaving IT for music, linking with Wizkid, going viral & new album | 'On In 5'

For this all-new episode of “On In 5,” singer-songwriter BNXN discusses his journey from IT to music, finding his voice and originality, linking up with Wizkid for their hits “Mood” and “Many Ways,” and what fans can expect from him this year — including a new album. Watch the full episode here!

  /  08.08.2023

The Auditions | 'Shoot Your Shot'

The competition begins at REVOLT WORLD as rising rappers, singers, and musicians line up to audition for their spot on the main stage. Brought to you by McDonald’s.

  /  11.28.2023

Investing in stocks in a recession | 'Maconomics'

Host Ross Mac provides useful advice for preparing your personal finances in the event of a recession. He emphasizes the importance of budgeting properly, building an emergency fund, and maintaining discipline when investing.

  /  11.21.2023

From city lots to lush gardens: The power of urban farming with Karen Washington

This is the inspiring story of Karen Washington, a pioneering urban farmer who has been revolutionizing urban spaces by transforming them into vibrant community gardens and educational hubs. Sponsored by State Farm.

  /  11.17.2023

Best chef's kiss | 'Bet on Black'

“Bet on Black” is back with an all-new season! Watch as judges Pinky Cole, Bun B, Van Lathan, and Target’s Melanie Gatewood-Hall meet new contestants and hear pitches from entrepreneurs Saucy D and Chef Diva Dawg.

  /  10.24.2023

Good taste test | 'Bet on Black'

With the help of host Dustin Ross and correspondent Danielle Young, entrepreneurs Diva Dawg, Brooklyn Tea, and The Sable Collective pitch their ideas to the judges. Watch the all-new episode of “Bet on Black” now!

  /  10.31.2023

Lauren London sparks conversation on how Black parents unintentionally give kids negative outlook on money

At the live taping of “Assets Over Liabilities” at REVOLT WORLD, Lauren London opened up about how witnessing the financial decisions adults made during her childhood fueled her outlook on money. 

  /  10.26.2023

Madam DA Fani Willis proclaims, “A lie has been told on African American men”

“Every time I’m in trouble, it’s been Black men that have come to my aid,” Madam DA Fani Willis said at REVOLT WORLD while speaking on the stereotype that they are not dependable or worth dating.

  /  10.11.2023
View More
Revolt - New Episodes